Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP), in very simple terms, is the process whereby modern businesses attempt to ensure they have the ideal amount of inventory to match sales with demand. Monthly S&OP facilitates the alignment of team efforts with the corporate strategy, from finance, sales, marketing, production, warehousing, shipping, management, and operations. The sales and operations planning process examines (at a minimum) production, sales, demand, and inventory data and uses it to prepare forecasts up to 18-36 months into the future, though these projections are continually analyzed, reviewed, and updated through regular S&OP meetings and processes.
Since data collection and analysis is fundamental to effective S&OP, many companies are tempted to use popular Business Intelligence (BI) tools such as Tableau and Domo for sales and operations planning. However, while general BI tools can be very effective for data aggregation and business analytics, they may not be the best fit for optimizing S&OP processes. Though BI solutions are useful tools for many generalized business applications, their limitations in the context of S&OP highlight the need for specialized, intelligent solutions that are purpose-built with integrated business planning (IBP) in mind.
Let’s go over the key concepts, benefits, and possible limitations of generalized BI platforms, and discuss the need for intelligent, purpose-built S&OP tools for optimized forecasting, planning, data structuring/visualization, and decision-making.
Business Intelligence tools like Tableau and Domo have revolutionized how companies gather, analyze, and visualize data. These tools allow organizations to pull data from multiple sources, easily create drag-and-drop dashboards, and generate reports that provide insights into business performance and KPIs. Popular, mature BI tools have dozens (or hundreds) of included, pre-built connectors for nearly all foreseeable business-related applications, cloud-based services, and databases, and a useful generic import/conversion/interface function for those that aren’t specifically supported yet.
BI tools are valuable for many use cases, such as financial reporting, marketing analytics, and customer insights. They are good at aggregating large datasets, particularly from diverse sources, making it easier for businesses to interpret complex information and make better, data-driven decisions. The user interface (UI) for building basic data visualizations has become excellent and intuitive.
For small-to-midsized organizations that focus on KPIs and basic data insights, particularly companies that don’t have dedicated data/technical teams, these BI tools can be ideal, if comparatively expensive. The entry-level interface is easy to use for users and teams with lower levels of technical knowledge. These general BI tools offer features like multiple built-in options for data visualization and real-time dashboard customization, and in some cases the platforms can stand in for dedicated data warehousing while businesses spin up more robust DW solutions. They can enable decision-makers to quickly identify trends, patterns, and outliers, providing a high-level view of overall business performance. However, fully staffed, advanced businesses with more complex data tasks, who want more customization than is offered, or who see the specific need for tools that optimize the S&OP process specifically, may find themselves frustrated or even bottlenecked with the general BI tools available, depending on what functions are desired.
S&OP is a process that bridges demand and supply planning, forecasting, production scheduling, and financial management, essentially involving all teams within a business, and often reaching outside entities. It requires a deep understanding of multiple factors, including demand forecasting/planning, inventory management, production capacities, and sourcing/supplier lead times. S&OP also involves aligning strategic business objectives with operational capabilities, which requires detailed planning, collaboration, and ongoing reviews/adjustments to forecasts and supply plans.
Unlike other BI use cases, effective S&OP requires more than just data aggregation and basic visualizations. To be effective, S&OP demands specialized tools that enable and support:
Although BI tools such as Tableau and Domo can be suitable for many business applications, their general-purpose nature makes them less appropriate for the specialized requirements of S&OP. Here are a few examples where a general BI tool might not measure up in some cases.
General BI tools are not designed specifically for S&OP. They may excel in general data aggregation, as well as easy-mode visualization/dashboards, but may not include the built-in functionalities needed for detailed, intelligent demand forecasting, capacity planning, or inventory management.
For example, without complicated and time-consuming customization, general BI tools may not provide the forecasting algorithms or optimization models that are essential for making accurate predictions about future demand, which is key in demand forecasting and supply planning. They also may not have the functionality to run simulations or what-if scenarios that help businesses understand the potential impacts of changes or disruptions at particular points along the supply chain.
Specialized S&OP tools, on the other hand, come with built-in functionalities that help create and maintain forecasts, track key metrics (e.g., RSPE, MAPE, inventory turns, customer service levels), and model various scenarios. These tools are purpose-built to streamline supply and demand planning processes, enabling users to adjust plans based on real-time data and input from different departments as well as outside sources.
BI tools typically focus on simplifying high-level data visualization rather than the data governance and consistency critical for S&OP. For example, aligning data from sales and operations in a way that accurately reflects supply constraints, inventory/warehousing crises, or real-time forecast adjustments requires significant effort in data transformation and structuring, which is not a core strength of some BI tools.
While many leading BI tools can simplify connection to a wide variety of data sources, they often require significant (and potentially expensive or time-consuming) customization to structure, integrate, and visualize this data in a way that is meaningful for S&OP.
Purpose-built S&OP tools are designed with integration in mind, and they facilitate the seamless flow of data across different functions. These tools also provide predefined data structures that ensure consistency and accuracy, which is critical for generating reliable forecasts and managing inventory effectively.
Scenario planning is a key aspect of S&OP, enabling businesses to prepare for uncertainties such as fluctuations in customer demand, supply chain disruptions, or unexpected changes in production capacity due to multiple potential factors. General BI tools are not designed to easily model these scenarios. While they can visualize historical data and trends, running complex “what-if” scenarios or sensitivity analyses often requires custom calculations and extensive manual work from an in-house data team, and at times BI software doesn’t make this kind of customization easy.
On the other hand, as noted above, purpose-built S&OP tools can offer theoretical planning capabilities that allow businesses to simulate different demand scenarios, evaluate their impact on the supply chain, and adjust plans in real time. These tools provide a more flexible and automated approach to sensitivity analysis, enabling organizations to make faster, more informed decisions and manage risk better. This helps businesses respond more effectively during unavoidable supply chain disruptions.
While BI tools may offer collaborative features such as shared dashboards, they may not provide the necessary workflow management or data processing speeds needed for optimal S&OP. For instance, sales teams may need to update demand forecasts at the same time supply chain teams need to concurrently adjust production plans. Without an integrated workflow designed with S&OP in mind, these tasks can become disjointed, leading to misalignments or errors in the final plan execution.
Purpose-built S&OP tools are specifically designed to handle the complexities of sales and operations planning. They offer built-in features for demand forecasting, supply planning, scenario analysis, and financial integration, and they allow for seamless collaboration across departments. These tools are optimized for integrated business planning, ensuring that organizations can align their operational activities with strategic goals while managing uncertainties and risks.
By using tools specifically designed for S&OP, businesses can make more informed decisions, improve collaboration, and better manage supply chain risks. While general BI tools have earned their rightful place in many other business functions, when it comes to S&OP, the need for specialized functionality, integration/collaboration, demand forecasting, inventory management, capacity planning, scenario analysis, and complex data structuring and visualization makes a purpose-built tool the best choice.
The ORI Excellence Platform is the only software and AI tool purpose-built to help you achieve top-tier sales and operations planning and execution in one place. Reduce risk, manage uncertainty, and increase resilience with ORI.
Get a free demo and find out how ORI’s 30 years of experience and best-in-class technology can help you.